Police in North Yorkshire are using lie detector tests as part of their efforts to tackle sex offenders. The use of polygraphs has been praised by some as an effective tool in identifying and tracking potential offenders, while others have raised concerns about their accuracy.
The police say the use of lie detector tests helps gather evidence for criminal investigations. They have been using it as part of Operation Resolve, which has seen offenders brought to justice. The process involves the offender being asked questions while hooked up to a polygraph machine.
North Yorkshire Police employ lie detector tests to address sex crime
North Yorkshire Police have recently introduced a lie detector initiative to address sex crime in the area. Following successful trials, the police force is using technology to aid investigations into a growing number of sexual assaults. The polyggraph tests are being used to narrow down potential suspects and determine guilt or innocence during suspect interviews. This strategy also enables fast-tracking of cases, meaning suspects can be processed through legal channels as quickly as possible with minimal resources required. It is expected to reduce pressure on North Yorkshire Police resources and increase conviction rates in sexual felonies.
At a public accountability meeting of the North Yorkshire Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner, the force’s head of safeguarding, Heather Whorriskey, revealed that officers have used a polygraph test 87 times since its introduction in October 2020.
At the meeting, Heather Whorriskey disclosed that the police force has used polygraph tests 87 times since October 2020. The tests aim to protect vulnerable people by enabling officers to identify false claims more efficiently. It is hoped the tests will help protect crime victims and increase accountability from perpetrators. Ms. Whorriskey expressed satisfaction with the force’s progress and commended their dedication to providing a safe environment for all citizens in North Yorkshire.
The police force considers the tests a “valuable tool” and will continue to use them, Det Supt Whorriskey said. The use of polygraph tests is increasing and will be used 13 times in the next three weeks alone. She added, the police force is committed to using the tests to catch criminals and bring justice to those affected.
“It identifies unknown risks and offences we would not have known about without the equipment. It’s absolutely value for money.”
Investing in sophisticated technology to identify unknown risks and offences has the potential to detect previously undiscovered issues and eliminate them. The cost of such technology may appear high, but its long-term value is unmatched. It prevents financial losses by avoiding risks and offences, and streamlines operations, saving time and effort. The technology is definitely worth the investment.
However, some critics say the tests are not always accurate and can lead to false confessions.
While lie detector tests may provide information and truth, some critics have voiced concerns over their accuracy. They suggest the results can lead to false confessions and innocent people being charged with crimes they haven’t committed. This highlights the need for further investigation and alternative evidence to properly conclude.
What is your view on the police’s new tactic? Do you think it is effective or fair?
Recently, some police departments have adopted a zero-tolerance policy for certain laws. This type of policy allows police to immediately arrest individuals suspected of breaking the law, regardless of the situation. While this may seem effective, it has been criticized as unfair. It is argued that the policy does not consider context when punishing people and can lead to discretion on the side of officers, resulting in inconsistent enforcement and inequity. It is important to evaluate whether this approach is the best going forward.